| Studyguide.org |
A Web Site for Mrs. Adams' English Classes | |||||||
![]() ![]() ![]() |
![]() |
![]() ![]() |
||||||
| Homepage | ||||||||
Essay
Rubrics
Over the course of the
school year, we will use a variety of rubrics to evaluate papers. Here is
a sample.....
Assessment Criteria: Standards and Criteria for Essay Evaluation
|
Standards |
Criteria |
|||
|
Areas of Assessment |
A |
B |
C |
D |
|
Format |
__includes typed final, prewrite or outline, marked draft, & Works Cited in prescribed format |
__includes typed final, prewrite or outline, marked draft, & Works Cited - some (minor) errors in prescribed format |
__includes typed final, prewrite/ outline, draft, & Works Cited, but insufficient editing of draft; several errors in prescribed format |
__ missing prewrite/outline, draft or Works Cited; insufficient editing of draft or outline; numerous errors in format |
|
Understanding of literature/ texts |
__ writing shows unusual insight understanding |
__writing shows strong, clear understanding |
__writing shows adequate understanding but may be too general or superficial |
__writing shows little or no understanding of text |
|
Idea Development |
__ presents fresh thesis in an original manner while displaying unusual insight |
__ presents an effective thesis and development using a consistent, careful manner incorporating examples |
__ presents a clearly defined thesis, but the development is too general or may not be marked by independent thought |
__ poorly defined or inconsistent development of thesis that displays little insight |
|
Text Support |
__more than adequate/correct MLA format; smooth embedding |
__adequate/some errors in MLA format; generally smooth embedding |
__inadequate/several errors in MLA format; some faulty embedding |
__inadequate/numerous errors in MLA format; ineffective embedding |
|
Organizational Pattern |
__ strong, interesting; clear beg/middle/end; strong thesis that is marked on draft |
__ organized; clear beg/middle/end; clear thesis that is marked on draft |
__ somewhat organized; attempt at beg/middle/end; thesis is weak or unclear - not marked on draft |
__ no attempt at organization; lacks clear beg/middle/ end; thesis lacking or inappropriate - not marked on draft |
|
Word Choice |
_ fresh/vigorous; contributes to "voice" __ very limited use of 1st and 2nd person & "to be" verbs |
__vivid/interesting; attempt to establish "voice" __ limited use of 1st and 2nd person & "to be" verbs
|
__ appropriate but not specific or vivid; weak "voice" __ weak attempt to limit use of 1st and 2nd person & "to be" verbs |
__ simple/vague; appears to lack "voice" _excessive use of 1st and 2nd person & "to be" verbs |
|
Sentence Structure |
__ correct/varied |
__ correct, but lacks variety |
__ sometimes incorrect & lacks variety |
__ frequent errors & lacks variety |
|
Transitional Devices |
__smooth & effective; marked on draft |
__ somewhat smooth & generally effective; most marked on draft |
__ many not smooth & some errors in usage; many not marked on draft |
__ not used &/or frequent errors in usage; many not marked on draft |
|
Language Mechanics |
__ very few (if any) errors; very well proofread |
__ few errors; generally well proofread |
__ several errors; requires additional proofreading |
__ numerous errors; appears not to have been proofread |
Questions? Email: adams@studyguide.org
**Many thanks to Michelle Garbis for her substantive development of this rubric**